Verdict
Destinations
Restaurant · New York

Peter Luger Steak House

The cash-only Williamsburg steakhouse, open since 1887, famous for its dry-aged porterhouse for two.

Independent — no pay-to-rank Graded for who you are Verified 2026-06-17How we grade →
The verdict

Worth the table for…

Great for
  • Couples
  • Foodies
  • Local-life seekers
Depends
  • Travellers on a budget
  • If you've only got a day
  • Families with kids
  • History & culture buffs
Not for
  • Solo travellers

Worth it for couples, foodies and local-life seekers; not for solo travellers.

What to order

The plates that decide it

  • Porterhouse for two (or three/four) — the only steak order that matters here; ordered by number of people
  • Thick-cut bacon, German fried potatoes, creamed spinach — the classic supporting cast
  • Fish or chicken from the menu — you came for beef — don't waste the trip
Why we say this

Insider secrets & local vibes

The dry-aged porterhouse for two is a benchmark American steak, carved and plated tableside in seconds of butter-basted sizzle.
Not independently verified — estimated
It's cash or a Luger account only — no ordinary credit cards — which catches people out at the worst moment.
Not independently verified — estimated
Service is famously brusque and the room divides diners — some find the gruffness charming, others off-putting.
Not independently verified — estimated
What it feels like

Reading the room, traveller by traveller

  • With friends

    A pilgrimage best done as a group so you can order the porterhouse for the table and the famous sides.

  • Couples

    The porterhouse-for-two is built for a pair, but expect a loud, no-frills room rather than romance.

Good to know

Before you go

Cost
~$120+ per head for the porterhouse experience
Time
1.5–2 hours
Last verified
2026-06-17
Best time
Earlier seatings on weeknights
Booking
Reservations strongly advised; bring cash
Accessibility
Bustling, traditional dining room
Was this helpful?
Make the most of it
Book through our partner — we may earn a commission, and it never changes the verdict.
Reserve a table
Independent — no pay-to-rank Graded for who you are Verified 2026-06-17How we grade →